I was talking to a writerly friend of mine the other day.
--Uh, I HATE talking on the phone, so I try not to do it, BUT when I do it's best to plan for a marathon. I can talk for HOURS . . . probably because I don't talk to myself when I write and when my kidlet and hubby are home, I can never get a word in edgewise!
Anyhoo, we bounced around various topics for over a couple of hours . . . yes, I said a couple of hours. We were talking about how different people handle criticism, whether it's a contest entry, a critique, or a reviewer dissing a book. Everyone deals with it in different ways, but she said something that struck with me, especially when someone comments negatively to your input.
WARNING: Tangent ahead:
Years ago, I owned a horse. I wasn't well off and it was all I could do to afford board, farrier, vet and one lesson a week. If I wanted to compete in Hunter schooling shows, I saved my money. Paying a trainer to work my horse was rare. I think I could count the times on one hand when I paid a trainer to work Buster (my last horse. I bought him green-broke--he knew how to stop . . . sort of). I had to figure it out for myself. If Buster didn't do what I asked, I had to figure out WHAT I was doing wrong. I obviously wasn't giving him the right signal. So I had to figure out how to communicate with Buster. It was a partnership. I LEARNED from the experience.
So, in other words, having someone else hop on your horse to fix it, what do you learn? Do you learn how to communicate better with your partner? Do you learn how to ask correctly? Do you learn ANYTHING?
--No.
Here are a few things to think about:
1) Before you publish:
--if you don't really 'want' input, don't ask for it.
--If you want your ego stroked talk to your mom, dad, sis, bro, or even your CP's, don't ask for a critique or submit as a contest entry. Different people pick up on different things.
--get over yourself.
--if a reader/judge/CP is confused about something, don't get defensive--get real. You're too close to the story. You KNOW what's going to happen, but you didn't do your job as a writer to give the reader enough information to understand.
--if you take everything a CP/judge tells you to 'fix' your story, you are writing yourself out of the story. Don't use their words to fix something, use your own.
2) After publishing:
--reviewers can be nasty, why give them power over you? It's not like you can do anything about your book. It's a done deal. It's in print. So what if they don't like it. Don't read reviews.
--true, it's easy for me to say because I'm unpublished. But you can't fix a published book, then why waste your emotions over something someone wrote about it?
I'm busy editing FAERIE, so . . .
Write on!
I know that some day I'll get a review that will make me cringe. But so far that hasn't happened, and I'm loving it! When that bad review happens, I'll probably take your advice. lol
ReplyDeleteI beg to differ. You learn a LOT from having someone hop on your horse to train it. You get the input and assistance from someone who has probably dealt with that exact problem before and can give you insight as to how to solve the problem without spinning your wheels for months (or years).
ReplyDeleteThere is no substitute for the wisdom of experience and for consulting with someone who has been there, done that. It will improve you and your horse light years faster than the 'blind leading the blind' method. It's also unfair to a green horse to have a gazillion false starts by a rider who doesn't really know what they're up against. Very unfair. (I'm not making a particular reference to you and Buster, just a general reference to the horrors I've seen riders inflict upon green, impressionable horses).
It's worth skipping a horse show (or three) to pay for the expertise of a professional. You owe it to your horse, if not to yourself.
I hope anyone reading this will find a way to apply this rant to an appropriate area of your life, otherwise accept my apologies for the fact that it was another two minutes of your life you can't get back. :)
I hope you keep getting the good reviews, Edie!
ReplyDeleteUh . . . OUCH!
ReplyDeleteI probably should have clarified about the riders that I was targeting in my rant, namely kids whose parents bought them more horse than they could handle.
I don't know how many times I saw a PRO ride a horse (at home or at a show) when the owner/rider wasn't around or even cared how the horse got 'fixed'. All they wanted was a horse that would win ribbons--which they usually did.
We are looking at the situation from different sides, Jody. I'm sure there are wonderful owners who strive to improve their performances with their horsey partners, but it hadn't been my experience observing that. Granted, it's been years since I've ridden, but this was what I remembered.
Margie, most people I know STILL only want a horse that wins ribbons. My barn is an exception - it's full of people who are horsemen, not merely riders, who love their horses and take part in every part of the riding/ training / management, much like you and I and Ellen and some of he others did at KJM.
ReplyDeleteUpon re-reading your post, I understand now what you were getting at - you were saying that people who just hand their horses over to a trainer and NEVER work WITH the trainer to understand what do to, don't learn a thing. And you're totally correct there!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Jody--I should have been clearer, but I wrote the blog on the fly and didn't reread it my normal three or four times. :-)
ReplyDeleteHm . . . I need to check out my Monday blog again.